Live Tech Showdown

Standard

So many times we talk about technology in the classroom, but an interactive classroom goes beyond just implementing great tech. Interactive tech has to be applied in a practical manner with a clean, simple implementation. In the past two weeks, I had the great opportunity to be able to test out multiple applications of interactive tech both from a student’s point of view and from a teacher’s perspective. To do this properly, I have to break them down to the basics. At the root of every category, I will seek to find the simplicity and minimalist structure forming each interactive system.

Teacher Usage
As I assessed my three main interactive websites from a teachers point of view, I found myself focusing once again on flow. For a site to be able to function intuitively in a classroom, it has to have an unobstructed flow to mace its implementation smooth and straight forward. With this in mind, Socrative stood out as a clear leader when it came to teacher implementation. Right from the login screen which had quick Google sign on and clean home screen perfect for smart board or Epson integration.

Now let me direct you to polleverywhere.com. This website holds so much potential, everything from taking a pole on a character in a novel, to hypothesizing on a science experiment, the possibilities in any class are so vast.. But its login window does not have a simple one Botton login like some of the others, and this could easily take away from your classroom flow if, you are logged out by accident. On the other hand, once you are on the page you can easily access everything from a clean and straightforward layout. You can tell right away that this system was designed for an interactive screen and a live presentation system. The booths on the side make it simple for a teacher to live to customize virtually every aspect.

Moving on to Padlet, I have mixed feelings about this site. First, it was ver easy and simple to sign on, because of the straightforward Google implementation. But here is where the flow seemed to begin to be disrupted, first it had an excellent organization, and design window on the left for each Padlet created. Since you had to scroll down and menus were hidden within menus, there was a disconnection when it came to pure creation. Then it completely lost significance in my teacher vision, when it would not save, even when switching programs and computers. This sent up red flags for its live implementation in the classroom.

Student Usage
Socrative once again does a fantastic job when it comes to implementation, from the separate login screen with simple code sign into clean integration with multiple devices. This can be made even easier if the teacher pays for a subscription plan, but even without it, the site shines as a clear leader from simplicity and flow standpoint. Being a student with multiple learning disabilities, I love how clean and organized it is, this create a distraction free implementation. Socrative speaks minimalist power from start to finish.

With cell phone classroom integration becoming an everyday occurrence, being able to engage your students in a positive way is key. Polleverywhere.com seems to have found a gold mine here with there text-based live interaction system. Though the flow at times might be hampered from infrastructure hitches, I believe the positive side outweighs this. Also, the ability for a student to be anonymous is impressive, especially if you have some student that are shy. They are now able to interact with the class as a whole, where else wise they might not.

Since I gave a bit of a scathing review of Padlet from the teacher perspective, they have a bit of a come back in the student integration arena. The ability to link pictures and ties in an interactive screen system that can be viewed live and commented on is amazing for multiple classroom implementations, On the student side, flow and simplicity shine brightly with minimal hiccups.

Flexibility, and Variety of Questions
If you haven’t already been able to envision my front runner now will defiantly make it clear. Socrative is a powerhouse of possibility. From quizzes, games and an exit ticket format, the options seem almost too much to handle. Not that there couldn’t be more but what they have already mage this site just phenomenal in any lesson. Now add the ability to have three question formats: Multiple Choice, True/false and Short Answer, and I say if you aren’t using this in your classroom now is the time to start.

Polleverywhere.com, on the other hand, is a little bit limited, in that it only takes a question and survey format. But then again what do you expect from a live polling app. The ability to ask questions and get an extended written response live is amazing in itself. Since it has designated itself to this realm of implementation, it has limited itself in a way, but in no way does this take away from its flow and relevance in any classroom.

On the other hand, Padlet has clearly set itself out as an instant classroom live blogging interface. By doing so it has limited its implementation to a write-up and a picture format, But I ask you is there any simpler way of getting your class into blogging than such a format? I know I haven’t fount one, and since its singular simplicity stands out from its counterparts, it holds its own in a field of giants.

Diagnostic Feedback
Here is where Socrative once again seals its place at the top, with only a free plan, a teacher has tremendous resources on hand. First, you have the ability to turn names on and off when you want to show the live class results. Then capacity to keep the data and return to it later is awesome, take that with the ability to print off reports in multiple formats and this site I would pay off any day to be able to use it to its full potential.

As we come to poll everywhere, well I can’t speak mush to this since I have not paid to be able to view reports and diagnostics. I found this to be a hindrance; mainly they are pushing you into a structured payment system to make it pay off in the classroom. The least they could have done is given a small print of a system with simple stats.

Once again we compare a system that seems not to be designed to fit the same box like the others. There is no real feedback section in Padlet since the posts themselves are comments in their right. You can print the page off if you need a hard copy and you can share it with your other resources and sites if needed. Ultimately just a great live feedback system that sticks around as long as you keep them.
Finally, after looking at all three in depth, I can say that they all play their parts ver well. The key is to know their positives and negatives well before implementation in the classroom. But in the end my number one pick is Socrative, second place is Padlet, even though it has shortcomings, and in third place is Polleverywhere.com, mainly because of the lack of results and reporting in the free version.

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Live Tech Showdown

  1. Mark Elson

    Hi Jonathan,

    Really great read, I think your whole blog website looks amazing. As far as your article goes I found it interesting that you though that Polleverywhere was so limited, I thought it was one of the most diverse tools with. I know it is intended to be a survey but I thought the fact you could use world maps, and the wordle like function were awesome. For kids and teachers I thought Polleverywere was one of the best tools out there.
    Also the write up you did on Socrative has made me rethink my choices, I did not put Socrative in my top 3. The way you talk about it makes me want to revisit Socrative and rethink my choices. It is free and full of great tools for teachers, students, and the diagnostics is great especially seeing as it is free. I know this is kind of a trap question but, If you had to use one tool in the classroom what would it be?

    Thanks for the read,
    Mark

    Like

  2. Kennedy Werre

    Hello Jonathan,

    Wow, I just have to say this, but your whole blog site is absolutely phenomenal, well done! I really enjoyed reading your perspectives on these different interactive systems and we have a lot in common and a few differences. It is very evident that you love Socrative, and I found a lot of positives from this site also. I love how easy it is to create an account from the teacher side and its free version, the applications go beyond most other interactive websites we’ve looked at. You seemed to have troubles with Padlet on saving? I never had this issue! I love Padlet as it allows for students to research topics and express what they have found with their fellow classmates, a great way to collaborate in my opinion. Since Socrative has so much flexibility in their questions, did you enjoy the website Spiral at all? This site was just as great for this aspect and it was simple as well.

    Thanks for the read!

    Kennedy

    Like

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s